So, being the chubby fitness instructor not only means I have a thick waistline, it means I have a thick skin. Regularly, the more voluptuous instructors have to work to win over the respect of students (that one is pretty easy) and colleagues (that one is not). While Zumba is very come as you are, the argument can be made that the big picture of fitness? Is not. It’s competitive like any other line of work, with lots of instructors of every type of fitness – from yoga to step class to indoor cycling – thinking what they teach is the best choice. I understand that, because I can be that way, too. I think that Zumba is a great hook to bring people into the gyms and studios and get them comfortable working out. But among some of the more hard core fitness instructors, Zumba isn’t a ‘real’ workout, and coupled with my chub (which is their proof), I’m sitting at the kids table at the Fitness Instructor dinner parties. I’ve actually been standing in a group of instructors at one gym where a spinning guy equated Zumba to the ‘ridiculousness’ of the pet rock. (I’m going to pause a moment and just let that sink in).
…
…
And I could tell you 5 more stories just like that one.
But this isn’t a post where I bitch, because honestly? I get it. In Zumba, there is an absence of elitism (Front Row Divas and glitter eyeshadow aside) and competition that exists in other types of athletic activities. The all-inclusive nature of Zumba is AWESOME for students even if it is seen as a drawback to other teachers. The atmosphere of a class is so encouraging and supportive that students gain confidence in all areas of their life, not just within the 4 walls of their workout party. And then they go on to become instructors themselves! Like, at a crazy rate I’ve never seen before in other group fitness classes. Zumba wants everyone who wants Zumba, if that makes any sense. Everyone can be a rock star, because everyone has one on the inside, just waiting to be released.
A couple of years ago I wrote about taking a TurboKickmy ass class. I struggled my way through the first one, went back to a second, and finally got to where I conquered it. And though I never loved it, it stuck with me. It all happened about the time I had a Twitter exchange with TurboKick creator Chalene Johnson – one like many others – where she criticized my handle, @MrsFatass. I invited her to come get to know me and understand it before she criticized it, and she did. We shook on it. Things seemed okay.
But in reading her tweets and FB posts, I never shook the feeling that I was a bit on the outside looking in. Like, her messages were being polite to people like me, but until I was “fit” (her definition thereof), I wouldn’t really get it. You know how people tilt their head to the side and act like they are right there with you? That’s the feeling.
And then it happened. IT. fingerquote IT fingerquote.
I was in a position to hear a conversation between a TurboKick professional and a student. “Well, TurboKick isn’t really made for beginners. If I were you I’d start out with something like Zumba, and work your way up.”
Again, I’ll give you a moment.
…
…
That was the minute I decided that someday I’d learn to teach that class. That poor woman. She’d made that hugely difficult decision to try something new. And worked up the nerve to talk to the instructor beforehand. And she was basically told she didn’t belong. And I decided then and there that I would singlehandedly change the TurboKick culture one day. Because fitness belongs to everybody. And when a beginner came up to me before class, I wouldn’t turn her way. I’d do my job and teach her modifications and give her encouragement and help her walk out of that room feeling successful, like I was able to do when I came back to class..
So, I went and got my TurboKick certification, and even at the training I felt like I had something extra to prove because I didn’t look like the other women there. And when we were doing the master class, I chose to do a lot of the modifications – more because of the fact that I’ve been through these things before and knew to conserve my energy than the fact that I couldn’t keep up, but I’m sure that’s not what some people thought – and I passed with flying colors. (Note: I met some really awesome women that day, too, who I continue to communicate with all the time. There were only a few who I know were sizing me up by my, uh, size).
When you go to one of these trainings, a very exciting part of it is THE SHOPPING. Because we all looooove hot gym clothes that advertize our favorite workout! But in the stacks and stacks of cute “TurboWear”, there wasn’t anything to fit me. Nothing! Not a thing! So I thought maybe she just sold out of XLs, or maybe she didn’t carry many of them. So I scanned the order form to see if I could order something to fit me. And there was nothing. Nothing to fit a newly certified, size 16 Turbo instructor.
I sat and listened to the trainer talk about Chalene, and how great she was, and how involved she is in the design and distribution of this clothing line, and I had money burning a hole in my pocket. But if I wanted to spend it, it would have to be on a boxy men’s tee shirt, not on the sleek, flirty, feminine pieces. And I absolutely refused to do that.
I sat there thinking about how I just spent a pile of money and time becoming certified to teach a class for a creator who thinks I’m too big to wear her clothing. AND IT PISSED ME OFF. That elite Turbo “culture” that I’d kind of been feeling seemed to be starting right at the top!
In the days that followed, I noticed a few things that sort of ‘supported’ that notion. In a conversation with my (awesome) trainer, she almost excused the instructor who turned the student away, even though we just learned in training how to teach in layers, and grow as a group, making the class accessible to everyone. “Maybe she was just carried away with Turbo fever!” she wrote me. And I was disappointed in that answer. Later, I saw a post somewhere about how cool it would be if Chalene designed a line of TurboKid wear. Which killed me because the current line isn’t for everyone, would a line of children’s clothing exclude chubby kids too?
And then a thread from Chalene herself, using the hashtag #FitGirlProblems. Which didn’t feel like something I could participate in. My Turbo Fever was diminishing quickly.
I was left feeling like an hourglass peg trying to squeeze into a Size 2 hole.
I knew if I got started teaching, I’d have wonderful students and we’d make the class our own and kick each round’s bootie. I knew people would come because they like me, and in time I’d have classes as populated as my Zumba/Toning/Sentao classes. But I felt like a hypocrite writing a check to a company who was willing to take my money, but didn’t seem to think I fit their ‘image,’ all the while, encouraging others to come out to take part when they might not fit in either. And god forbid I somehow steer a student into a situation where they, too, feel excluded, perhaps in another class, or with another instructor, or when trying to buy a Turbo shirt, or in seeing one of these social media messages that makes her feel the way I was made to feel. I couldn’t live with myself!
And as I learn the round and get in front of students with it, I’m struggling. Just like the victory of conquering the class was somehow tainted by what I overheard, the victory of the certification just isn’t as sweet when I still feel like the outsider. I am having a hard time finding the passion for teaching it, because of all of this backstory. Even though it could lead to my seat at the grownups table, I think I might rather stick with the pet rocks.
So, that’s my #GroupFitnessProblem. What’s yours?







Twitter
Facebook
RSS
{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }
All of this is so true…love Zumba, love your classes, love you! No group fitness problems yet, but i’m still kinda a newbie! I would love to take your Turbo class….you are just plain awesome. That’s all. <3
I have thought about adult and children’s synchronized swimming at the YMCA I go to. Most classes are taught by volunteers and I have taught it elsewhere in the past and I could pass the exam for my instructors certification fairly easily although that is not required. The thing is I am just not interested in the struggle as a fat woman to be taken seriously. I have a friend that is an excellent Spinning instructor and I see that for many people it doesn’t matter how hard her workout is or how good it is, they will not be seen in a fat woman’s class. The ridiculous thing is that she is the preferred instructor for two triathalon atheletes who are in better shape than anybody I have ever met. This woman has a hundred stories of being insulted, denied and pushed aside and she just keeps going. Not for me! So our YMCA has no sychronized swimming classes.
Hey, I still have my pet rock. Stone Phillips has been a part of my life since… what? WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU THREW HIM AWAY, ANITA? THAT ROCK WAS MY BEST FRIEND!!!
When I was just out of high school, I was asked (by my hairdresser) if I’d like to come and join her at her other job, teaching aerobics. I was a runner, not a dancer. But I checked it out. She told me she liked my energy and had the perfect class for me: low impact. I decided to give it a try, and I loved it. Great workout. Being a sprinter for many years, I had hamstrings and quads of steel, so my body was built for that kind of “work.” (Didn’t hurt that I was 18.) Nearly ALL of my students were obese. Some were elderly. Occasionally, I’d get someone who was rehabbing an injury. And I saw how my students were treated by the people who went to other classes, as if they didn’t exist or didn’t deserve to be there. It taught me a very humbling lesson: Fitness is for everyone. We all pay the same membership dues, one way or another, and I know many of my students weren’t there to meet dudes or keep themselves busy. They were there because they were serious about getting healthy, no matter what class they took. It’s total bullshit when others exclude you from fitness endeavors based on your size. If it’s important to you to be there, it should be important to them, too.
Yes! Yes! Yes! Everything you said is soooo true, Sue. I can’t believe I had the nerve to walk into my first Zumba class, but because of the atmosphere, comrodery, and smiles, I kept returning. I’ve been asked why I don’t participate in other classes. I’ll be honest and say that I did try once, I walked in and was looked at as if I didn’t belong and felt that way too, so I left never to return again. Is Zumba the “best” workout? Hell yes! You know why? Because I keep going back! Anything can be great, but if I don’t go to it, then really, how great can it be?
We all are, because we are who we are. And I am so thankful of that, and thankful for you and all you’re doing to improve not only your life, but also the lives of those around you. I know all the others in your classes would agree. So, girlie, chin up! No one HERE is judging you. We love you just the way you are.
So Sue, I’m really sorry that Turbo Kick has insulted you. You’re braver than I because I never would have stepped in the door in the first place! And as for your size, I don’t understand the problem. You are perfect, right!
I have been reading your blog for a loooong time – through finding your Zumba love, through your hard year, through your silences – and I am finally going to comment! YOU ROCK. I think you are smart and funny and sexy, and I’d totally do your Zumba class. But here’s the thing: turbo is more my style. Not because I’m fit (I’m not) but because Zumba freaks me out and I have no rhythm and I get lost. So I personally would be delighted to walk into a turbo class and find your curvy butt in the front of the room…
I read this yesterday and have left it open on my computer, because I knew I had to comment but wanted more time to process a reply. I’ve decided to just tell my experience with Zumba. When I finally got my obese butt to join the gym 9 months ago, I knew I needed group fitness to get the results I wanted. But wow, was that intimidating!! Large groups of women that all seemed to know each other and all these “new-fangled” classes I had never heard of when I worked out regularly 15 years ago (because they didn’t exist!) I saw so many people on facebook talking about their love of Zumba I decided to try it. I hated it. Literally, hated it. I decided my body was just not made to move that way, I could not shake my hips like that in public and I felt like I was always lagging behind the instructor. All this led to barely breaking a sweat and making me feel like it was a waste of the precious hour I had to work out that day. I didn’t want to go back. Ever. Then one day, Zumba was the only class being offered during the time I could be at the gym. I tried it again. SAME EXACT EXPERIENCE, even with a different instructor. I was sure I could never, ever learn how to do all those complicated moves and turns and hip shakes. It was just not the least bit fun or rewarding. I never have danced and have no rhythm and totally blamed my lack of coordination in the class on that. However, I was a cheerleader in high school and I could learn tons of cheers, so I decided to try one more time. I HAD to be missing something if it was so popular, right? This third try I had Sarah Zumba Nagle as an instructor. I left that class feeling happy, empowered and thrilled with Zumba. She was awesome. She didn’t over complicate the moves, they were fun and offered enough repetition for me to actually learn them. I discovered right then and there that not all instructors are created equal. Not every Zumba class is fun. There are some instructors that are really, really great dancers and have beautiful, involved, complicated moves that are simply impossible for someone with less experience to keep up with and it destroys the fun and kills the workout.
After Sarah’s class, I talked to some other gym members and was given two more names of the “best” Zumba intructors. They were Sue and Sam. I learned they were exactly right. I know now that if you want to know how good the instructor is, check to see how full the room is during their class.
So, I said all that to say this: There is elitism and judgement in all group fitness. What makes the class is the instructor and you are an amazing instructor. I want an instructor that “gets” how hard it is to step into that room and start making a change. Someone that hasn’t forgotten that becoming fit is a journey and we all start from a different place. Someone that understands they are making a difference in every student’s life in every class that they teach.
Because of you, someone no longer needs insulin because fitness was fun and attainable to them. Another person doesn’t get out of breath climbing the steps to tuck in their kids because you helped them have fun building up their endurance. Someone finally has the confidence to go clothes shopping again because you helped them love and accept themselves again. Don’t ever let size limits of a clothing line or derogatory comments of snooty, self-absorbed elitist make you feel like you aren’t good enough. You are beyond amazing and I could never thank you enough for all you have done that has helped me on my journey to fitness!!
I can understand how you would feel that way about Turbokick. I would too, honestly. But I would stick with it, just to create your own wave, to show other girls like us that we can DO this TOO regardless of any crazy hashtags, or lacking of apparel. We CAN do this, we can do anything that is in our hearts, just like you taught ME remember?
My biggest problems with group fitness classes is instructors who don’t understand how to modify their class (or don’t take the time to do so) for people who have previous injuries and things. I’ve had to learn many of my own.
I’m self-conscious so I also don’t like when other students look at me funny when I am modifying. That’s one reason I really like Zumba because I’ve had great instructors that teach the basic steps before making it harder each song.
Don’t let the snobs keep you from trying new things. That being said, I tried a turbo kick class a few years ago and hated it! I was two steps behind the entire class the whole time. I was so frustrated that I didn’t know the moves!
Hmm…but in SF, zumba is the most competitive class I’ve taken out of all the classes I’ve tried. That’s why I have often not been a fan of it. People line up like they’re gonna die if they’re not first, and they complain, so the gym’s started giving them numbers. They get in according to their # and literally RUN into the room and to their special favorite spots. Once there, they make sure to take up as much space as possible, glaring at others to fend off their area. I took a class with the most popular zumba teacher once and wow, that thing was so scary I never went back. I was doing ujam which is like zumba, but with more modern music and without the competitiveness, but they rearranged the schedule and it’s become zumba. We have a fairly new teacher, and he’s not super popular yet. It’s fun, and we do have to do the line up by number thing, but so far they’re not totally out to kill, so I am trying it out. But really, this class (in any of the different gyms, with any of the teachers) is SO scary n unwelcoming, compared to: pilates, yoga, piyo strength, bodypump, cxworx, turbokick or any other class I’ve tried. Now turbokick, I LOVE that class! When I take it with my fav teacher (which is now only Sunday mornings so I hardly get to go) it’s SO FUN! I’ve even gone to bed early, leaving a club, on a Saturday night so that I could wake up and go to my turbokick class. There’s such a sense of yay, we’re all here having fun together-ness and it’s just like a giant party. But anyway, we have people of all ages, sizes, gender in all my classes. And no one wears the clothes of the classes, not even the instructors. It’s just interesting how backwards the class experiences are here in SF to where you are. But then again I’m on the student side and you’re on the instructor side. Anyway, exercising should be about having fun.
The scariest part of going to any class when you are larger than the regulars is that you will not fit in. To have a teacher tell someone that is just insane! It took me 3 years to really give zumba a good try and I love it thanks to the teacher and the freedom. To be honest I sweat more in zumba than spin or any other class! I avoid the classes that have the barbie looking instructors for many reasons.
I think what you are doing is amazing and putting yourself out there gives more people like you and I and so many others the confidence to try it out. There is so much comfort in seeing someone similar to you doing amazing things. Every time I see one of your zumba updates or posts I am so envious that you are not near by. If you were teaching any other class I would feel the same because you obviously teach with heart. That will go farther than anything else ever. You will be the instructor that makes a difference to people. Don’t ever let anyone take that from you! It is never easy putting yourself out there for others but it is so worth it in the end.
{ 1 trackback }